As we are all in Coronavirus lockdown and unable to hold events and celebrations to commemorate this important anniversary, Peter Mansfield author of “The Bates Method” and founder of The School of Vision Education invites us to re-read the original book. Reading and reflection are perfect for these current times when all of us who are not key workers find ourselves mostly indoors with our usual activities cancelled. With uncanny foresight, he made this suggestion at a gathering of Bates Method teachers just before the pandemic took hold. 

Re-read with discretion

Peter: This year 2020 is the centennial anniversary of the publication of Dr Bates’s book, The Cure of Imperfect Eyesight. My proposal is that anyone who is involved or interested in this work might like to take it on themselves (and I’m going to do it) to very carefully and very slowly read or re-read that book in its entirety. 

I think it is a book that needs reading carefully and with discretion because in what he writes there are things which are crystal clear and obviously completely right, things that may appear to be clear at first sight but on second reading you might think well what exactly does he mean by that? There are also some passages where it may well be that what he is saying, especially on some of the scientific passages is not right. He may fall into occasionally wanting to, let’s say, bend the research results to fit what he wanted which people can do. And it seems to me that it’s actually a very useful thing for those involved in the work to be familiar with all of those questions.  

I think in my reading and annotation of it, I’m quite certain that there are things that Dr Bates stated which are in fact not necessarily completely correct. But the fact that those particular points aren’t correct doesn’t undermine the method at all. So for example when he says categorically that the lens is not a factor in accommodation I think that’s very much open to dispute, but in practice, it’s marginal, it doesn’t make any difference because all the practical things that he’s talking about work perfectly well. I think it’s quite clear that the lens does play some part in accommodation, it’s just not the whole story.  

I think it would be a very good time for everyone who is involved and interested in natural eyesight work to have a look and re-evaluate and make sure that we know what we’re talking about.

The full book is available here. With thanks to Esther ven der Werf visionsofjoy.org for this link.

Author Anna Bambridge

More posts by Anna Bambridge
Share