The History of Bates Vision Education in the UK
An unbroken teaching lineage from Dr. W. H. Bates and Emily Lierman
The Bates Method has been practised and taught in the UK for over a 100 years. This is an account of this history. With such a scope there will be teachers missed and mistakes made. Gratitude to all who carried the torch and apologies for the inaccuracies and omissions lost in time.
Learning from Bates himself
In the 1920s Captain Cecil Price travelled to New York from England and learned from Bates himself. Back in London he passed on his knowledge to Mrs White-Cooper and Kate and Ethel Beswick who formed the London School of Eyesight Training which was running from 1925. Two sisters who were nurses, Marie and Olive Scarlet came to the school .
Meanwhile, Madeleine Fousset, a wealthy woman of French heritage, had a riding accident and injured her face. She travelled to New York to see Dr Bates to seek help and as she sat crouched in his waiting area he walked past and said “It’s no good you sitting there hiding your face, we’re going to sort you out.” And they did. She learned his methods from him and Emily Lierman and brought the knowledge back with her to London.
Teaching others in London: Miss Fousset and the Misses Scarlett
Madeleine Fousset then taught Evelyn Sage (who was very formal and didn’t like using first names so we will call her Miss Sage).
The Scarlet sisters also spent time with Madeleine Fousset and the number of people being taught the Bates Method in London increased and in the 1940s the London Eyesight Centre was formed. Some of the teachers at the time were Miss Brock, Doris Moss, Mrs Pearl and Jeanne Neveaux (Aldous Huxley’s sister-in-law). The two who were mostly responsible for passing the Bates Method on to the next generation, however were Michael Ronan and Miss Sage.
The Bates Method teachers were very aware of the trouble that Bates himself had had with his work being recognised and there was a sense of being cautious about attracting too much attention. One teacher, a Scottish woman called Mrs Pearl was doing work with disabled children and there was an article in the paper about it. Some of the other teachers were disapproving of this and said that they didn’t want to attract publicity.
Miss Sage
Miss Sage worked at the Bank of England but at the age of 50 she left to teach the Bates Method full time. She ran her training twice a week. There was a clinic on a Wednesday where the students would see clients under her supervision, and on a Friday they would work through Bates’s book together.
Miss Sage spent time with Peter Scott one of the first Alexander technique teachers, They would share each others work and, as with many others have, found philosophical and practical similarities between the Bates Method and the Alexander technique with the ideas of relaxation and “not doing”.
Miss Sage’s students Margaret Montgomery and David Glassman remember her fondly.
“Miss Sage had a certain manner and some kind of magic that other people didn’t”
“She would say to people -What is it you don’t want to see? – which maybe they weren’t ready for.”
“She taught me to see colours and to see in three dimensions. She showed me how to appreciate pictures. I owe her a lot.”
“She loved M. Fousset and her beautiful shoes!”
“She’d say – Seeing has got nothing to do with the eyes. Get away from exercises!”
Among her other students were Brigitte Cavadias (who later ran trainings in France) and
Gloria Ginn who also studied with Olive Scarlet and took their Bates Method teachings back across the atlantic to the USA.
The actor Terence Stamp took lessons with her and much appreciated her. When he heard she had died he came and spoke at her funeral.
Ronan, Attenborough, Mansfield
Also in London an artist called Anthony Attenborough learned the Bates Method from Michael Ronan. So when a musician called Peter Mansfield came along wanting to learn Michael, who wasn’t teaching any more suggested that he go and see Anthony.
Peter quickly took to the Bates Method and had lessons with Anthony 3 times a week. He then trained as a teacher with Anthony along with Wendy and Michael Kent getting their certificates in January 1986.
This was a time of optimism in the complementary health fields before regulation and a general mistrust closed in again. There was a sense then that it was becoming more mainstream. Big newspapers and magazines were publishing prominent positive stories about the Bates Method. There was the Institute of Complementary Medicine in London and a trend for groups (e.g. reflexology, homeopathy and massage practitioners) to come together and form associations. The Bates Method teachers did the same and in 1985 at a meeting of the London Eyesight Training School with Michael Ronan, Miss Sage, Anthony Attenborough, Peter Mansfield, Michael Kent, Wendy Kent, Laurence Howell, Steven Cooper and Margaret Montgomery (Olive Scarlet couldn’t attend as she was unwell) the Bates Association of Great Britain was formed.
Vision Education
Peter Mansfield then went on to run teacher trainings and write a book about The Bates Method. He felt that the wording “Eyesight Training” that had been used felt too restrictive and too focussed on the eyes so he coined the term Vision Education to describe Bates Method teaching. He felt that it described working with and through vision and also being an educational process rather than a medical one meant not being subject to as much political scrutiny and protocol.
In the light of this the association was renamed the Bates Association of Vision Education. Peter Mansfield also travelled to the USA and spoke at a gathering of teachers in Virginia Beach where an association was also being formed. His wording struck a chord there and so the Association of Vision Educators was born.
Peter ran trainings from 1991 – 2001 assisted by Margaret Montgomery. These consisted of one weekend per month for 2 years. Over 50 people came through this including Ajay Sehgal and Patrick Mahoney who offered trainings in 2002-2003, Nina Hutchings (who with Brigitte Cavadias started the trainings and association in France), Julia Galvin who pioneered online videos of Bates Method teaching, Kevin Wooding and Lizzie May who offer online training for new teachers, and Aileen Whiteford.
College of Vision Education
In 2004 Aileen Whiteford and Margaret Montgomery formed the College of Vision Education and over 13 years and 7 training groups taught 38 students. This training was a 200 hours in-person training in London. One of the noticeable differences was the international nature of these courses. As well as UK students people also came from Bulgaria, Belgium, Taiwan, Japan, Sweden, Slovakia, the USA, Germany, Ireland, the Netherlands and Italy. Aileen and Margaret also organised the British Natural Eyesight Conferences in 2008 and 2010.
Now the work is truly international and the next generation is discovering it. Thank you to everyone past and present who has devoted and is devoting their passion and time to studying, practising and sharing the Bates Method. Learning to see is as vital as ever.
Compiled from the memories and archives of Anthony Attenborough, Peter Mansfield, Margaret Montgomery and David Glassman by Anna Bambridge.