Seeing is a physical, intellectual, emotional and spiritual process
Bates teachers know very well that in working with their clients’ mental strain and stress for better eyesight, they also have to treat the therapeutic dimension of their vision, not just the organic. For this, we need a system of values to approach the person’s insight and global dimension. This can be approaches of the body, the mind or both. For some, it is yoga or any other therapeutic way. I am trained in psychoanalysis, and soft body approaches and I want to show the links between the work on external vision and its beneficial effects on the internal vision, the overall psychic health.
Bates and Freud
Freud launched his “Interpretation of Dreams” in 1901, his first great book and the basis of his theory. Dr Bates published his “Perfect Eyesight without Glasses” in 1920. What are the links between their work?
Freud developed ideas about psychic functioning in 3 parts; the conscious, the unconscious and in between the subconscious. He also described libido as the drive-in an energetic sense, the bond of love between a subject and object. The subject from which the desire begins and the object on which his desire is directed. This covers not only sexual love but also parental love, filial love, love of friends, love of animals, books, music, objects, and ideas. It encompasses a curiosity for the outside world.
Bates said “There is much more involved in defective vision than merely an inability to see the blackboard or to use the eyes without pain or discomfort. Defective vision is the result of an abnormal condition of the mind.”
What did he mean by mind? We can think of the mind as a construction of our intellect, learning, and experience, part of our conscious and unconscious way of being that responds to, directs and adapts to everything we do. Thus Bates conceived the unconscious part of human functioning, the same one that Freud investigated as a central object of study.
Movement for balance and change
In the centre of the retina (the part of the eye that collects light), there is a spot called the macula, an area of maximum sensitivity, with a small indentation in the middle, the fovea centralis, this is the point with the greatest visual acuity.
In order to see well, the eyes constantly move from one point of interest to another or from a part of an object looked at to another part to have more details of what we are looking at. A relaxed curiosity directs where to look. If we force to see something, if we strain, we stop the movement and our eyesight declines.
Our sight consists of 5% central vision (details) and 95% peripheral vision (context). This is why peripheral vision is very developed in the Bates Method and yet so little practised in modern life.
Bates method movement practises develop the relationship between the centre and the peripheral visual fields and the experience of dynamic relaxation. This will increase the saccadic movements of the eye. By associating our consciousness to these movements, we accept better the movement of life. It makes us work the physical balance, the balance of both eyes and the balance of thoughts too, the ability to anticipate and accept change.
Linking our external and internal realities
The external reality is created by the internal reality and vice versa.
The natural movement first goes from self to the world, from the internal unknown, invisible, to the external, known, visible. Being interested in our eyesight means becoming aware of the opposite direction from the world towards oneself, from the external to the internal, from the visible to the invisible, letting go and being carried by the world, not controlling everything by looking.
The look of love or hate
To look at the eyes is to touch the soul of a person. In the two extremes of human feelings, love and hate, the gaze is at the forefront. We absolutely need the other to see ourselves. We do not see ourselves entirely, we never see our eyes except in a mirror, and the first mirror is the eyes of the mother. Thus, the baby gradually becomes conscious of itself rocked in the arms, in the eyes and by the voice of its mother. He thus constructs an image of himself, which allows him to grow and have emotional maturity. Later we will always need the eyes of the other to exist.
Eyesight to Insight
For me being a Bates teacher is a way to gather my experience of Psychology, my experience of pedagogy and my experience of the knowledge of the body through internal Chinese exercises, tai chi and eye yoga. My work is to accompany my clients towards visual autonomy and more broadly to self-knowledge and self-awareness. The practice of vision education is one in which eyesight is in a permanent relationship with insight.
This post is a summary of a project completed in May 2017 as part of the requirements of the Vision Teacher training with the College of Vision Education. With thanks to Anna Bambridge for her help in choosing the essential arguments for this blog post.
Beatrice Pauly-Laubry teaches in Paris, France.
